Mrs O’Brien walks across a vast salt flat toward the low sun, her long shadow stretching back
AMERICAN CINEMATOGRAPHER · AUGUST 2011 · EMMANUEL LUBEZKI, ASC, AMC
Shooting The Tree of Life
Terrence Malick’s Palme d’Or winner, lit almost entirely by the sun, under rules the crew called “the dogma”.
Lubezki holds a light meter up beside the pipes of a church organ
Lubezki meters the light on a church organ.
THE BRIEF
Find the shots, don’t set them up
Malick pairs a 1950s Texas childhood with cosmic questions that echo the Book of Job, on a scale the magazine compares to 2001. It was Lubezki’s second film with him, after The New World. Malick was deeply prepared, but wanted it to feel unprepared, like a documentary.
THE DOGMA
Rules for shooting
Rule
Why
Available natural light only
Sky, cloud and grass all colour a face
Never underexpose
True blacks, no milky images
Compose in depth
Deep focus and a deep stop
Backlight; never front light
Continuity and depth; front light is flat
Negative fill
No “light sandwich” of equal sources each side
Short, hard lenses; only a polarizer
Clean, sharp images up close
Z-axis moves; no pans, tilts or zooms
Move through space, not across it
“Article E”
Accept the exception
Lubezki: art is made of constraints. The rules even contradict each other: backlight brings flares.
THE FORMAT
Close, wide and fine-grained
Shot 4-perf 35mm at 1.85:1, not anamorphic, because the camera was so close: often 1 to 2 feet from faces, hands and feet, mostly on 14, 18, 21 and 27mm primes. Just two stocks, 500T and 200T, and no 85 filter, so the colour was balanced in the grade.
Extreme close-up of a baby’s eye and hand
Intimate close-ups put you inside the family’s moments.
Mrs O’Brien kisses her sleeping son’s forehead in warm window light
Mrs O’Brien and her son, in window light.
TERM · 85 filter: an orange filter that balances tungsten film for daylight.
BACKLIGHT
The sun behind them
A backlit face gives no clue to the time of day, so shots cut together: summer can sit beside winter. When Jack’s father teaches him to fight, both are backlit, a physical impossibility nobody notices. The film began with a “no flares” rule, but backlight made flares a motif.
A boy splashes through a river with the sun flaring behind him
A boy charges into the river, sun flaring behind.
A boy, back to camera, faces his mother in the yard, the sun behind her
A son faces his mother, both lit from behind.
TERM · Backlight: light from behind the subject that rims them and lifts them off the background.
Mr O’Brien at the piano in profile, with his son playing guitar in the doorway behind, thirds lines and boxes drawn over them
1
2
3
My reading of the frame, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
Father and son
  1. The father fills the right third, eyes down to the music.
  2. R.L. plays guitar deep in the doorway, framed by the door.
  3. Sheet music in front adds a third plane.
TERM · Composing in depth: stacking people on separate planes, front to back.
Mr O’Brien at the dinner table with his sons, window light behind them
Tensions mount during a family dinner.
CHASING THE SUN
Three houses, one home
Like Edison’s studio on a turntable, the crew used three houses facing different ways: east rooms in the morning, west rooms later. Jack Fisk turned a dining-room wall into glass. The editors called the result “Cubism”: one scene, several houses.
TERM · Continuity: matching details from shot to shot, broken here on purpose.
EXPOSURE
Riding the iris
T8 to T1.3
Following kids from sun into cloud, the stop could swing that far in one take.
No bounce boards
White cards would show. At one dinner Pitt sat 2 stops darker than the boy by the window.
Film’s latitude
Shooting out of the house at T2, clouds near T64 still held their detail.
TERM · Latitude: how many stops of light and dark film can hold at once.
THE CAMERA
Ninety percent without a tripod
Three cameras were ready every day: Arricam Lites on Steadicam and an EasyRig, plus an Arri 235 for run-and-gun. Operator Joerg Widmer and Lubezki swapped when a magazine ran out. 1st AC Erik Brown pulled focus with no marks, guessing where the actors would go.
Crew with a camera crowd around the family at the dinner table
Widmer (centre, black shirt) moves in for an over-the-shoulder.
A toddler’s legs beside an adult’s on the grass, seen at ground level
Steadicam in low mode, down at a child’s height.
TERM · Low mode: Steadicam rigged upside down to fly the camera near the ground.
SERENDIPITY
Sending in a torpedo
Malick dropped surprises into scenes, like another actor, a dog or the operator running through, to shake out natural moments. When a butterfly flew past, Lubezki grabbed the 235 and caught it landing on Chastain’s arm. In the edit, anything that felt intentional was cut.
A butterfly lands on Mrs O’Brien’s outstretched hand
The butterfly on Mrs O’Brien’s arm.
Seen from inside, a window shatters as boys stand outside
Jack lashes out at a neighbour’s house.
TERM · Jump cut: a cut inside one shot that skips time, so the image visibly jumps.
A small figure walks away through a grove of tall trees, thirds lines and a box drawn over him
1
2
3
My reading of the frame, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
A cathedral of trees
  1. A small figure, dead centre, on the lower third line.
  2. Trunks rise like the columns of a church.
  3. The brightest gap sits right behind him, pulling the eye.
TERM · Natural framing: using things in the scene, like trees or doorways, to frame a subject.
NIGHTS
Never a stand in the house
Light that follows
In the boys’ room, a 2K in a Chimera on a hand dimmer was carried by whoever wasn’t operating.
Real sources
Photofloods over the dinner table, flashlights, and a desk lamp a boy could play with.
Minutes of blue
Jack’s dusk walk was shot over several evenings, in the 15–20 minutes the sky still read.
TERM · Chimera: a soft box that fits over a light to soften it.
THE CREATION
The universe in a water tank
The 20-minute creation sequence had to avoid any sense of a human hand. Douglas Trumbull of 2001 ran weekend “Skunkworks” shoots with liquid tanks, dry ice and flashlights through glass paperweights. One nebula was half-and-half poured into water, shot in slow motion.
A towering brown and teal nebula of gas and dust
A nebula from the creation sequence.
A dinosaur stands over another on a rocky riverbank in a forested valley
Dinosaurs over background plates shot on 65mm IMAX.
TERM · Element: a separately shot piece of image, layered with others in compositing.
CHEAT SHEET
Tech specs
Aspect ratio
1.85:1, 4-perf 35mm
Cameras
Arricam Lite · Arri 235
Lenses
Arri/Zeiss Master Primes and Ultra Primes, mostly 14–27mm
Film
Kodak Vision2 500T 5218 and 200T 5217 · no 85 filter
Finish
Digital intermediate at EFilm with a custom LUT: prints have better blacks, the DCP more sparkle
Crew
Operator Joerg Widmer · 1st AC Erik Brown · production designer Jack Fisk
Schedule
12 weeks, mainly in Smithville, Texas
FOR COLLEGE
Four ideas to write about
Rules as style
How the dogma’s limits shaped the look, contradictions included.
Backlight and continuity
Light chosen so shots cut together, not just to look good.
Found, not staged
Torpedoes, chance and documentary method inside fiction.
Editing as memory
Cubist continuity and jump cuts as the way Jack remembers.
Cite it (Harvard): Benjamin B (2011) ‘Cosmic Questions’, American Cinematographer, 92(8), pp. 28–39.
← cinema