Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson in keepers’ uniforms in front of the lighthouse
American Cinematographer · Nov 2019
The Lighthouse
How Jarin Blaschke shot Robert Eggers’ sea-madness tale on black-and-white film, wartime lenses and a homemade 1890s look
The setup
Two keepers, one storm, 1890
The two keepers arrive on the rocky island below the lighthouse
A crusty old captain (Willem Dafoe) and a haunted ex-lumberjack (Robert Pattinson) start a four-week shift on a remote New England island. The storm never stops.
Page 1 of the script
35mm black-and-white film
1.19:1 frame
Eggers wrote both rules in before anything else.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
2
Scale
The shoot in numbers
35 days
of filming, with one camera
70 ft
working lighthouse, built for real on location
1,200 lb
custom acrylic lens spinning at the top
12 miles
nautical, how far out to sea the beam reached
3
nor’easter storms the set survived
1.19:1
frame, narrower than old Hollywood’s 1.33
American Cinematographer · November 2019
3
Format
Why not shoot colour and convert?
Blaschke tested three options side by side. Real black-and-white film won.
Arri Alexa
Digital. Clean, but none of the physical texture he wanted.
Kodak 5219 colour
Colour film is made of tiny clouds of dye. Smoother, softer texture.
Kodak Double-X · winner
Chunks of real silver at different depths. Bigger grain, more “tooth” and more local contrast.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
4
Frame
Almost a square
2.39:1 · widescreen
1.85:1 · standard
1.33:1 · silent era
1.19:1
Eggers keeps pushing narrower: his shorts were 1.33, The Witch was 1.66. Blaschke floated 1.19 as half a joke, and Eggers loved it.
From years of square-format still photography, Blaschke knew it suits portraits. It frames the tall tower, and traps the two men together whenever they share a shot.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
5
The two keepers stand either side of the lighthouse tower, thirds lines and boxes drawn over them
1
2
3
READING THE FRAME
Two keepers, one tower
  1. Old Tom sits lower, gazing off, pipe in his mouth, the senior man at ease.
  2. Winslow stands taller and stares at the camera: the challenger.
  3. The lamp both men will fight over sits dead centre, between them.
TERM · Symmetry: balancing a frame around its centre. Here the tower splits it like a wall.
My reading of a publicity still. Lines show the rule of thirds.
The 1890s look
Film that couldn’t see red
Blocked: yellow, orange, red
400 nm · violet
570 nm cut-off
700 nm · red
Early “orthochromatic” film only recorded ultraviolet, blue and green. Blaschke recreated that, which does three things:
Skies
Blue sky records bright and blank, like 19th-century photos.
Skin
Skin is mostly red light, so faces go darker and more bronzed.
Texture
Blemishes and lines stand out, so the keepers look weathered.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
7
The filter
A filter drawn on graph paper
What he tried
Light lost
Result
Cyan colour-correction filters
Very little
Far too subtle
Strong 47 Blue and 58 Green filters
3–4 stops
Film drops to ISO 12–25: unusable
Custom filter: cut everything above 570 nm
5/6 stop daylight, 1⅔ tungsten
The look, without the darkness
Ron Engvaldsen at Schneider Optics made it from Blaschke’s hand-drawn graph. While it was being built, they tested with a small lab filter taped inside the front of a lens.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
8
Lenses
Glass from 1840 to 1944
Blaschke wanted the lenses to have a say in how the period looks, without tipping into kitsch.
Main set · Baltars
Made 1941–44
Not the familiar Super Baltars. They let lots of blue and UV through, perfect for the ortho look, and make highlights glow.
Flashbacks · 1905 triplet
Thimble-sized
An uncoated brass 50mm, rehoused by Panavision’s Dan Sasaki for a couple of flashback shots.
Big moments · Petzvals
Swirling edges
A design from 1840. Sasaki built a 35, 58 and 85mm. Backgrounds swirl hard towards the edges.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
9
References
What they watched
Film or filmmaker
What they took from it
Béla Tarr
Dreary tones, a patient camera
Ingmar Bergman
Camera language, as always
In Cold Blood
Strong, hard night lighting
Man of Aran
Ortho film, bold direct close-ups
Sergei Eisenstein
Montage and hard cuts
M · biggest influence
Early-modern visual language
Pickpocket · biggest influence
Close-ups, especially of hands
Robert Eggers directs Robert Pattinson on the rocks by the sea
American Cinematographer · November 2019
10
The lamp
“We were getting calls from out at sea.”
The custom lighthouse lamp threw a beam 12 nautical miles, and fishermen noticed.
The lens
Eight-sided acrylic, 1,200 lb, about $100,000. In glass it would have cost $1 million.
The bulb
A 6K HMI, far brighter than the household bulbs in real lighthouses, so the beam shows on film.
The surprise
It was only meant to sit on set. The crew got it 70 ft up into the real lantern anyway.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
11
Interiors
Lit by the lantern itself
Dafoe and Pattinson eat at a table lit by a single oil lantern
Night · ISO 50
An 800-watt halogen bulb hidden in the table lantern. Netted so it falls off fast, plus a small China lantern behind it later on.
Day · ISO 80
Windows wrapped in white muslin, with two M90s and up to two 18Ks bouncing into it.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
12
The keepers eat supper either side of an oil lantern, boxes drawn on the lantern and both men
1
2
3
My reading of the frame, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
Supper by lantern
  1. The lantern is the light: a practical in the middle of the table.
  2. Old Tom on one side, in deep shadow.
  3. Winslow on the other, lit by the same flame.
TERM · Fall-off: light dims fast as it travels, so faces glow and the room drops to black.
Location
Four hours from help
Cape Forchu, Nova Scotia, was so remote that anything they needed had to be built on the spot. Key grip Craig Stewart built most of it.
No crane? Build a cable-cam
A 100 ft Technocrane wasn’t available, so a homemade rig rode up the whole 70 ft tower.
The mermaid scene
A 40 ft pier held a 50 ft crane over the sea. “Moonlight” came from two lights on a 125 ft crane 500 ft across the bay.
The real-built lighthouse on the rocky cape, with a crane beside it
American Cinematographer · November 2019
14
Cheat sheet
Tech specs
Item
Used on The Lighthouse
Frame
1.19:1, 4-perf 35mm
Camera
Panavision Millennium XL2
Lenses
Bausch & Lomb Baltar, Petzval
Film
Kodak Double-X 5222 black-and-white
Filter
Custom Schneider, cuts above 570 nm
Lab
FotoKem, Burbank
Grade
Digital, Joe Gawler at Harbor, New York
Blaschke and Eggers beside the Panavision camera at the lighthouse railing
Source: “Stormy Isle” by Patricia Thomson, American Cinematographer, November 2019
15
FOR COLLEGE
Four ideas to write about
Recreating film history
A custom filter fakes 1890s film stock that couldn’t see red.
The frame as a cage
A 1.19:1 frame squeezes two men into a tall, narrow box.
Motivated light
The lantern really lights the scenes, so darkness is the default.
Black-and-white as a choice
Real black-and-white negative, not converted colour, for a different texture.
Cite it (Harvard): Thomson, P. (2019) ‘Stormy Isle’, American Cinematographer, 100(11), starting p. 60.
Also in November 2019
The rest of the issue
Film
Behind the camera
Ad Astra
Hoyte van Hoytema, ASC, FSF, NSC, with director James Gray
Gemini Man
Dion Beebe, ASC, ACS, with Ang Lee: high-frame-rate 3D
Lucy in the Sky
Polly Morgan, ASC, BSC, on an astronaut’s mind
Creative Collaborations
ASC members and their key collaborators
Ad Astra is the Neptune voyage from the space-film list: worth reading next.
American Cinematographer · November 2019
17
← cinema