Batman silhouetted against an orange sunset over Gotham
American Cinematographer · June 2022
The Batman
How Greig Fraser, ASC, ACS lit the darkest Batman yet, without losing the man inside the suit
The cinematographer
From studio cleaner to the Oscar
Fraser failed his first year of uni, then took a job cleaning a Melbourne photo studio. In 2022 he won the Oscar, BAFTA and ASC Award for Dune, all in the same year.
Fraser holding a lens on the set of Lion
Lion · first Oscar nomination
Fraser filming Timothée Chalamet in the desert for Dune
Dune · the Oscar
Fraser on The Mandalorian’s LED volume set
The Mandalorian · pioneered LED walls
Fraser with director Adam McKay on Vice
Vice · with Adam McKay
Fraser with crew on Zero Dark Thirty
Zero Dark Thirty · with Kathryn Bigelow
American Cinematographer · June 2022
2
His one rule
The Batsuit is fake. The light can’t be.
Fraser says humans have evolved to read light. People can’t always say why an image feels wrong, but they know. So every lighting choice, lens and camera move has to feel honest, however fantastical the story.
American Cinematographer · June 2022
3
Robert Pattinson as Batman in a dim, cluttered room
Lighting the suit
“You’ve got to see into his eyes.”
Too much light and Batman stops being scary. Too little and you lose Pattinson inside the suit.
So Fraser found a sweet spot: light in the eyes, kept off the cowl and jaw. It was so precise that Pattinson often had to be his own stand-in.
American Cinematographer · June 2022
4
Batman in the cowl in a cluttered room, boxes on his eyes and a blurred shape in the foreground
1
2
3
My reading of the frame, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
Eyes, not the suit
  1. Light finds his eyes inside the cowl while the suit stays black.
  2. A blurred shape in the foreground: we seem to be spying.
  3. He faces frame-right, into the space in front of him.
TERMS · Dirty frame: something soft in the foreground. Looking room: space left where a character faces.
Gotham Square Garden
A ceiling made of light
A huge glowing soft box hung over the outdoor arena set at night
687
single Digital Sputnik light cubes
200 × 170 ft
soft box hung over the arena
7 weeks
for the crew to build it
American Cinematographer · June 2022
6
The one daylight scene
Cathedral windows that weren’t there
The mayor’s memorial set in the gothic City Hall, with camera crew
Camera side: stone-coloured fabric with window shapes cut out
The back of the giant fabric gobo, with rows of lights on scaffolding
Back side: lights bounce off the gobo, then shine through the cut-outs
The real windows were added in post. A trick from Dune: instead of greenscreen, use fabric coloured like the set, so bounced light already has the right colour.
American Cinematographer · June 2022
7
Batman’s silhouette against an orange sunset over the city, boxes on him and the sun
1
2
3
My reading of the frame, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
The sunset
  1. A silhouette: pure shape against an orange sky.
  2. The sun sits just beside him, flaring the frame.
  3. The city spreads out on both sides: him and his territory.
TERMS · Silhouette: lit only from behind. Backlight: light from behind the subject, toward the lens.
The memorial’s power bill
3,600 kW
From a self-described “LED guy” who finds big wattage embarrassing
Each side of the set had 30 24K Dino lights and 15 Quarter Wendy lights, plus six 20Ks, all bouncing into a 120 × 130 ft white cloth. No LED had enough punch.
American Cinematographer · June 2022
9
Lenses
Sharp in the middle, falling apart at the edges
Sharp: frame here
Soft, smeared edges
2.39:1 frame
Soft, smeared edges
Arri Rental retuned its very clean Master Anamorphics for Fraser. He rejected the first version as too clean, and fell for the unfinished Series 2 prototypes.
The soft edges forced him and Reeves to keep the action in the centre, which keeps your eye on the story in fast cuts.
American Cinematographer · June 2022
10
The Penguin car chase
$50 lenses off eBay
For cameras bolted to cars, the big Alfas were too heavy, too soft at the edges and too expensive to crash. So Fraser used old Soviet Helios and Jupiter stills lenses, rehoused for cinema by Iron Glass in Ukraine.
An oval aperture cut-out makes their bokeh look anamorphic, so they match the rest of the film. Cheap Alexa Classics became the crash cameras.
A woman looks out of a rain-covered car window at night
American Cinematographer · June 2022
11
In camera
Raindrops made of silicone
The chase happens in a downpour, but a mile of rain towers was too costly and wasteful. They wet the road and cars, then added falling rain in CG.
Problem
Spray from the wet road splashed the lens at random and sometimes wiped out the picture.
Too far
A Bright Tangerine Prodigy rain deflector kept the lens dry, but now the image looked too clean.
Fix
Clear glass filters dotted with silicone blobs: fake raindrops that catch the light the same way every take.
American Cinematographer · June 2022
12
The finish
One extra step beyond Dune
On Dune, the digital master went out to film and was scanned back. Here they added a second film generation, for more control over the “film effect”.
01 · Digital master
Graded with colourist Dave Cole at FotoKem
02 · Negative
Recorded to Kodak 2254, ISO 1, with skip-bleach for glowing highlights
03 · Interpositive
Contact-printed onto the same stock. Both rolls get scanned
04 · Pick per shot
Close-ups: the positive scan. Wides: the sharper negative
American Cinematographer · June 2022
13
Cheat sheet
Tech specs
Item
Used on The Batman
Frame
2.39:1
Cameras
Arri Alexa LF, Alexa Classic for crash cams
Main lenses
Arri Rental Alfa anamorphics, Series 2
Chase lenses
Soviet stills glass rehoused by Iron Glass, Atlas Orion
Film-out
Kodak Vision3 2254, negative and interpositive
Gaffer
Jamie Mills
Also in June 2022
Top Gun: Maverick · Claudio Miranda, ASC and Joseph Kosinski on real high-flying shots
Dan Sasaki · the Panavision lens maker who built The Lighthouse’s Petzvals
Source: “Truth in the Image” by Jay Holben, American Cinematographer, June 2022
14
FOR COLLEGE
Four ideas to write about
Lighting eyes, not suits
Faces carry the story while the black suit melts into the dark.
Flawed lenses on purpose
Sharp centres and soft edges pull your eye to the middle of the frame.
Cheap glass, big film
$50 eBay lenses for the chase: character over perfection.
A hybrid finish
Digital capture, with an extra film-out step for texture.
Cite it (Harvard): Holben, J. (2022) ‘Truth in the Image’, American Cinematographer, 103(6), pp. 24–36.
← cinema