Colm by a stone wall and Pádraic on a lane, with cows, sea and grey sky behind
SHOOTING · AMERICAN CINEMATOGRAPHER, FEBRUARY 2023
The Banshees of Inisherin
How Ben Davis, BSC shot a falling-out on an Irish island like a Western.
2.39:1 · ARRI ALEXA MINI LF · SIGNATURE PRIMES
Ben Davis looking through a director’s viewfinder on a rocky location
Ben Davis, BSC (left) and Martin McDonagh on location in Ireland.
THE BRIEF
Stormy, but never dreary
Martin McDonagh wanted a storm-swept island off Ireland’s west coast, but told Davis it had to look beautiful, not grim. It was their third film together, after Seven Psychopaths and Three Billboards. With a small crew and limited kit, Davis says he went back to his origins.
THE SETUP
Lifelong friends, until one of them stops talking
Colm (Brendan Gleeson), a musician, tells dairy farmer Pádraic (Colin Farrell) he never wants to speak to him again, and threatens to cut off his own fingers if Pádraic tries. Davis expected a comedy. He found it sad at heart, and loved that about it.
GOING WESTERN
A Western in disguise
Davis had always wanted to shoot two men in a standoff. Here the saloon became an Irish pub, the horse a miniature donkey called Jenny, and the showdown moved to a beach facing the Atlantic. The voice of reason, he notes, is a woman: Pádraic’s sister Siobhán.
Inside a dark pub, Colm sits at a table while Pádraic is seen outside through the window
The saloon: a pub wall separates the former friends.
Pádraic walks across green hills with a small black donkey
The horse: Pádraic walks his donkey, Jenny.
THE REFERENCE PILE
What they watched to prepare
Film
Shot by
Why it mattered
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford (2007)
Roger Deakins
Davis’s main Western reference
The Searchers (1956)
Winton C. Hoch
The look Jesse James echoes
Shane (1953)
Loyal Griggs
Same classic Western language
Stagecoach (1939)
Bert Glennon
Watched together in prep
The Night of the Hunter (1955)
Stanley Cortez
McDonagh’s favourite: animals, silhouettes
All five are worth a watch for college: they show where the film’s standoff framing and silhouettes come from.
Colm behind a stone wall and Pádraic on the lane, with thirds lines drawn over the frame
1
2
3
4
Reading of the frame is mine, not the magazine’s. Lines show the rule of thirds.
READING THE FRAME
The lane
  1. Colm sits near the left third, hemmed in by the stone wall. He doesn’t look up.
  2. Pádraic stands on the open lane near the right third, watching. The empty gap between them is the story.
  3. The horizon sits on the top third under a heavy sky: a wide shot that keeps them small.
  4. The wall is a leading line, a barrier before anyone speaks.
THE ISLAND
Inishmore, in the rain
Most of the film was shot on Inishmore, the largest Aran Island. It rained on the scout and still looked beautiful. Davis photographed it on film and digital to work out how it made him feel: beautiful, but claustrophobic. About 75 crew moved kit in small vans, because the walled lanes are too narrow for trucks.
Crew with camera and boom on a grassy hillside at dawn, actor standing by the sea
The crew sets up a scene at dawn with Kerry Condon.
CASTING THE WEATHER
The weather was written into the script
Opening: a glorious morning, before Colm’s announcement
As the feud grows, the storm clouds gather
Siobhán leaves on a glorious morning
Before the shoot they gave each scene its weather, then each day picked which scenes to shoot by looking at the sky. The band shows the idea and isn’t to scale.
TERM · Pathetic fallacy: when weather or setting mirrors what a character feels.
SETS
Built to shoot in and out
Threshold work
Lots of shots look through doors and windows, so the sets had to work as interiors and exteriors at once.
Pádraic’s house
Built from scratch on a hill over a bay, because no old house had the right view.
The pub
Built on Achill Island, about 60 miles north, with real stone walls and a thatched roof.
McDonagh wanted dramatic coastline in shot, so you always feel how cut off these people are from the rest of the world.
Dark pub: Colm sits right, Pádraic seen small through the window at left, with boxes drawn around both
1
2
3
4
Reading of the frame is mine, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
The window
  1. A frame within a frame: the window boxes Pádraic in, small and far away, behind glazing bars.
  2. Colm fills the right side, close to camera, turned away. Size shows who holds the power.
  3. Practicals: the oil lamp and wall lamp are light sources you can see in shot.
  4. Bright daylight outside, a dark pub inside.
COLOUR
Lighting the pub like a Dutch painting
Black ceiling
So faces lift off the dark.
Dark-green walls
The pub’s main colour.
Van Gogh yellow
Inside Colm’s house.
Bold costumes
The landscape is muted, so clothes carry the colour.
References: Rembrandt and Terbrugghen. For the pub music scene, about 30 small 150W tungsten Dedolights hid in the rafters, making pockets of light around the lamps. Swatches are approximate.
TERM · Chiaroscuro: strong contrast between light and dark, as in Rembrandt’s paintings.
THE CONFESSION
One eyelight, one cross of light
A 150W Dedolight right behind the camera puts a sharp light in Colm’s eyes, so you feel his despair. Behind him, a cross of light reads as sun through a window. The priest gets a softer cross, projected with gobos and a Source Four.
Colm in a dark confessional with a glowing white cross behind him
Colm (Brendan Gleeson) in the confessional.
The priest in near-darkness with a soft cross of light on his face
The priest (David Pearse), lit through gobos.
TERMS · Eyelight: a small light that puts a sparkle in the eyes. Gobo: a cut-out in front of a lamp that projects a shape.
Colm sits alone at an outdoor table with a pint, green hills behind him
Colm drinks a pint in solitude. The hills behind him stay readable.
FACES AND DEPTH
“I wanted to see the weather on their faces.”
Large-sensor cameras like the Alexa Mini LF usually get used wide open for very shallow focus. Davis went the other way: close-ups at T5.6, sharp from eyes to ears, with the background kept readable. Cutting from landscape to face never jumps.
TERM · T-stop: lens aperture measured by the light that gets through. Higher number, deeper focus.
CHEAT SHEET
Tech specs
Aspect ratio
2.39:1
Camera
Arri Alexa Mini LF (large format)
Lenses
Arri Signature Primes
Close-up stop
T5.6
Pub lighting
About 30 × 150W tungsten Dedolights
Locations
Inishmore and Achill Island, Ireland
Crew
About 75, with gear in small vans
FOR COLLEGE
Four ideas to write about
Genre transposition
Western tropes moved to 1920s Ireland: pub for saloon, donkey for horse.
Pathetic fallacy
The weather was planned to mirror the feud: bright at first, then storms.
Chiaroscuro
Dutch-painting darkness in the pub, with faces lifted out of black and green.
Deep focus, against the trend
A large-format camera stopped down to T5.6, so faces and landscape match.
Cite it (Harvard): McCarthy, T. (2023) ‘Irish Drama The Banshees of Inisherin Explores a Fractured Friendship’, American Cinematographer, 104(2), pp. 56–59.
← cinema