AMERICAN CINEMATOGRAPHER · DECEMBER 2021 · GREIG FRASER, ASC, ACS
Shooting Dune
Villeneuve’s Arrakis, framed for IMAX, lit by the real sun, and finished out to film and back.
Fraser with Denis Villeneuve on location.
THE BRIEF
Dreaming in 4:3
Villeneuve told Fraser early on that he was dreaming about the film in 4:3, so they planned it for IMAX. Interiors were shot on stages in Budapest and the deserts on location in Jordan. Production designer Patrice Vermette was one of Fraser’s key partners.
THE FRAME
Two shapes of screen
1.43 for destiny
Full IMAX for Paul facing his destiny, and for nature: Caladan, space and Arrakis.
2.39 for the rest
The whole film was also designed to work in widescreen, for cinemas without IMAX.
Two kinds of glass
Spherical Panavision H Series for 1.43. Ultra Vista 1.65x anamorphics for 2.39.
Close-ups stayed looser than usual: on an IMAX screen, a face can be 70 feet tall.
TERM · Anamorphic: a lens that squeezes a wide image onto the sensor, here by 1.65x.
LIGHTING THE ART
The real sun as a key light
Fraser tried to light sets to match Vermette’s concept art. The Nexus is meant to be 300 ft tall, too big for any stage, so it was built open-topped under a 60 × 60 ft fabric gobo, scaled with forced perspective, and shot only between 10:45 and 11:10am.
Vermette’s concept art for the Nexus.
The set, with the gobo’s sun shadow on the floor.
TERM · Gobo: anything placed in front of a light to cut its shape.
DESIGN AND COLOUR
Colour from nature
Caladan
Canada’s coast in autumn: grey mist, mossy rock, blues and greens.
Arrakis
Sandstone and bronze, under white-hot skies rather than romantic blue.
Lit, then painted
Gaffer Jamie Mills lit each set before the final paint, so painters worked under the real lights.
TERM · Colour rendering: how truly a light shows colour. Cheap LED work lights do it badly.
SANDSCREEN
Fabric instead of greenscreen
Some sets were taller than any stage. Instead of greenscreen, the tops were finished with fabric painted the set’s average colour, so light bounced the right tone and VFX had a real shape to match. Walls were raked with fake daylight; faces were keyed with soft sources.
Leto meets Stilgar: walls raked with daylight.
Paul before a sandworm mural.
TERM · Set extension: the digital top-up of a set beyond what was physically built.
HOT, HAZY SKIES
Taking the blue out
Villeneuve wanted Arrakis skies hot and hazy, like Abu Dhabi in summer, with no blue. A LUT built in prep pulled the blue and rolled off the highlights. In Jordan, Fraser skipped the polarizer, which would have deepened the blue, and the grade finished the job.
TERM · LUT: a look-up table that maps camera colour to a chosen look.
Rabban supervises the invasion of Arrakis.
1
2
3
My reading of the frame, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
The test
- Paul stands near the left third, half turned away.
- The veiled Reverend Mother sits on the right third, almost part of her chair.
- Dark floor and an empty chair fill the gap between them.
TERM · Negative space: empty area that carries meaning, here the tension of the test.
Lady Jessica in the light-well hallway.
LIGHT WELLS
Sun that never comes in
On Arrakis no sun enters through windows; it’s bounced down light wells. In the 150 ft hallway, Chroma-Q Studio Force II strips gave punch, shape and a strip of light on the far wall, matching the concept art. For close-ups, Mills swapped in Digital Sputnik lights.
TERM · Sourcey: light that clearly seems to come from a real source.
COLOUR AND DEPTH
Depth with colour
Best light for faces
Digital Sputniks and Creamsources went on the actors: RGB light for an RGB sensor.
Not monochrome
Veins of red and blue in the sand walls, and subtle gradations in the costumes.
Graded on set
Dailies colourist Chris Rudkin graded the light itself, through the dimmer board.
TERM · Dimmer board: a desk that controls the level and colour of every light.
1
2
3
A set photo, not a film frame. My reading, not the magazine’s.
READING THE FRAME
Waiting at the door
- Jessica stands tiny, just right of centre, on the lower third.
- The huge round door frames and dwarfs her.
- A lamp on a crane arm plays the sun; in this set photo the rig shows.
TERM · Scale: a tiny figure against vast architecture, to show power or isolation.
IN THE SAND
Fraser on the camera
Fraser operated himself, hanging beneath an ornithopter rig and shouldering the A camera in the dunes. The shoot ran 5 weeks in Hungary, 4 in Jordan, then 14 more in Hungary. He hired 2nd-unit DP Katelin Arizmendi after finding her work on social media.
Fraser hangs beneath an ornithopter with Brolin and Chalamet.
Fraser shoulders the A camera.
TERM · Splinter unit: a small extra crew shooting pieces at the same time as the main unit.
THE FINISH
Out to film and back
Tested everything
35mm, 65mm 5- and 15-perf, and digital 35, full frame and 65. Digital came closest.
Film-out
The graded master was laser-recorded onto Kodak 5254 film, then scanned back for final touches.
Why 5254
ISO 1, so very tight grain, plus halation, gate weave and softness for an organic feel.
TERM · Halation: the glow round bright highlights as light scatters inside the film.
CHEAT SHEET
Tech specs
Aspect ratios
2.39:1 · 1.43:1 IMAX
Camera
Arri Alexa LF
Lenses
Panavision H Series (spherical) · Ultra Vista 1.65x anamorphic
Lighting
Digital Sputnik DS, Creamsource, Chroma-Q Studio Force II
Finish
FotoKem: out to Kodak 5254 film and scanned back, colourist Dave Cole
Crew
Gaffer Jamie Mills · 2nd unit Katelin Arizmendi · designer Patrice Vermette
Where
Stages and backlots in Hungary · deserts in Jordan
FOR COLLEGE
Four ideas to write about
Two ratios, two meanings
How switching to 1.43 marks destiny and nature.
Designer and DP
Fraser and Vermette as a model creative partnership.
Practical over digital
Sandscreen and a real-sun gobo versus greenscreen.
Digital with a film soul
What the film-out adds to a digital image.
Cite it (Harvard): Holben, J. (2021) ‘Fear Is the Mind Killer’, American Cinematographer, 102(12), pp. 16–29.
Also: Holben, J. (2021) ‘Creative Synergy: Cinematography and Production Design of Dune’, American Cinematographer, 102(12), pp. 10–14.